Skip to main content

Modernist Restoration

 A couple of days ago I spotted an excellent example of Modernist architecture up for auction in Houghton, Johannesburg. It must have been a jewel in its heyday, with striking three-dimensional treatment complemented by rolling lawns. It appears to be largely unaltered, offering plenty of scope for restoration.

House on auction November 2024: all photos from auctioninc.co.za

The entrance is very modest, emphasised by an overhanging rectangular volume on a slender steel column. The main feature of the house, the semi-circular bay windows, project to the right and the entrance door is tucked away to the left. The volumetric articulation has an affinity with the works of Erich Mendelsohn, the German-born architect who emigrated to the UK in the 1930s. This is interesting, as most of the modernist architecture in Gauteng is inspired by the French architect, le Corbusier. 
The entrance

Moving round the house, the bay-window motif is repeated, inviting the viewer to experience the striking volumetric treatment. The bay windows allow views right through the building, which serves to dematerialise the geometric forms. With the severe treatment of the roofline, the building takes on an uncompromisingly abstract appearance.

A side entrance with two projecting wings with bay windows
Moving into the inside, a curved staircase with a simple masonry balustrade echoes the curved forms of the exterior, with a dramatic flow of space. It would seem that a handrail has been removed, but not clear whether this was part of the original design. Given how little this building has been changed over the years, the handrail may well have been a simple steel tube that has rather unceremoniously been ripped out.
The staircase from the upper floor
Views of the interior show a dramatic flow of space, with austere detailing that expresses the structural articulation in the open-plan layout. This combined with the large expanses of glass give a sense of floating, the dematerialisation of the exterior echoed in the spatial quality. 

One of the rooms on the ground floor, with the structural beam expressed in the open-plan layout
The kitchen is the one part of the house that will require some refurbishment, to restore the sink and adjacent countertop. This room may also need adaptation in the plumbing and electrics to meet the needs of present occupants. Ideally, any alterations should match the original detailing, or if this is not possible, the simplest and most minimal designs should be chosen. 
The kitchen sink and countertop have been removed

Fortunately, the one wall of kitchen fittings has been preserved, with open shelves above the simple cabinets below, and closed cupboards up to the ceiling. 

A wall of original cabinetry in the kitchen.

Overall, the house is largely in pristine condition, and as such would be perfect for restoration. Ideally, its setting in rolling lawns should be preserved, but this is unlikely, given its location - many of the other houses in Houghton have been demolished to make way for cluster-housing because the land values are so high and the properties are so large. One hopes that this jewel will be preserved, possibly with a development on the rest of the site that is in sympathy with its architectural character.

Architectural restoration is a topic that has been debated since the Victorian era, with two diametrically opposed viewpoints. The one approach aims to match existing materials and detailing, so that any adaptation blends with the original, while the other approach seeks to differentiate the new work from the old, so that the history of the building is evident and the new work visible through contrasting material or colour. 

An interesting middle-ground has been taken in the Johannesburg Contemporary Art Foundation (JCAF) in Forest Town in Johannesburg. Here the restoration architects selected a face-brick that is subtly different from the brickwork of the old tram terminus, so one can "read" the recently filled-in panels, but the overall effect is harmonious. The alterations and additions in the building show a deep appreciation of the scale and materiality of the original buildings.

With any project in a building that has historical and architectural significance, it is important to consult with a reputable conservation architect. She or he will be able to give the best design advice and will know the best contractors and craftspeople to employ, who will have experience working with older methods of construction and more traditional materials. The Heritage Portal has a listing of recommended conservation architects.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Welcome to my blog

Sitting outside the Wits Architecture Building My name is Anne. I have just retired from the University of the Witwatersrand in Johannesburg, South Africa where I was an Associate Professor in the School of Civil and Environmental Engineering, working in the environmental engineering and project management domain. Prior to that, I was a lecturer in the School of Architecture and Planning, teaching many aspects of architecture, including architectural history, design and skills in graphics. Before lecturing at the University, I worked briefly in local government as a junior architect and then in a commercial firm of architects. After this I ran a private architectural practice with a focus on architectural heritage design. I have qualifications in architecture, construction management and employment creation through construction. Now that I have retired, I want to continue to provide educational context about architecture, engineering, design and project management in a different forum ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Pergolas

  While packing to move house, my daughter found some sketches that I had done several years ago for a pergola outside her living room. The room has full-height glazing across the entire width of the east-facing room, making the whole flat very hot in summer. Pergolas are an excellent way of adapting your indoor temperature, especially if you use deciduous plants to cover them, providing shade to the window in summer and letting the winter sun into the room when the plants lose their leaves. They are one of the most cost-effective and environmentally sensitive ways to adapt indoor climate, on any sun-facing side of your home. In the southern hemisphere, pergolas or awnings can be quite narrow on the north side of the building - the sun angle at mid-day is about 70 degrees on the equinoxes, so the depth of the pergola should be about half the height of the window or glazed door so that the sun is not blocked through the winter.  The angle of the sun in summer, winter and at the...
Post a Comment
Read more

Flower Hall: Wits

As a child, I remember going to the annual Rand Show, hosted by the Witwatersrand Agricultural Society, one of the highlights of which was visiting the Flower Hall - a vast space carpeted from wall to wall with flowers. In more recent times, the land on which the Rand Show was housed was taken over by Wits, the University of the Witwatersrand, thereby doubling the area of the main campus, the original lands of which are immediately to the east. The soaring roofs of the Flower Hall: photo Jennifer Fitchett Wits has retained several of the original buildings, many of which have been retained largely in their original form, such as Hall 29 (used as a basketball venue and doubling up as a large exam venue) and the Wits Club and Alumni House which used to be the wine tasting venue at the Rand Show. Other buildings have their shell retained, but remodelled interiors, and the most ambitious recycling project was the Science Stadium, which ingeniously reused the stadium seating for the large l...
Post a Comment
Read more